Favorite Reporter

Favorite Reporter

Wednesday, January 21, 2015

Dear Diary: Losing Sucks.

Losing Sucks.

In case you were not following last week, my Men’s curling Team – Un bloque et 3 Bleuets – lost the provincial Men’s final to Jean-Michel Ménard 7-2.

Losing the provincial final sucks.

First prize: A dream trip to the Brier in Calgary; money, the chance to be on TSN (and RDS), the chance to play in front of 15,000 fans plus a big trophy.

Runner-Up Prize: A big bowl of NOTHING. Nada. Zip. Had to pay $5.50 for my post-game rum and coke.  TPHPTT.


At least in big cashspiels losing the final is usually accompanied by a cheque that is 60-70% as big as what the winner gets. But there is no second place at provincials. Everybody says “congratulations”, but it is always said with trepidation, as if they know that it is not the appropriate response.
To be honest, The game was never really that close. We came out strong, and had a chance to take the lead in 2 but an ill-timed pick resulted in a steal, and we were suddenly down 2 points to a team that you cannot afford to be down 2 against. JM and his team are merciless front-runners. They hit very well, and force you to play ultra-aggressively just to keep a few rocks in play. Then they don’t miss, which means you end up having to make crazy shots just to scrape out a deuce somewhere, which we could not manage to do. We spent the last few ends flailing like baby seals on an ice float, waiting as the guy with the big stick approaches.
JM and Team seemed to dominate this year like no other. They went undefeated against a strong field, and never even really had a close game (except for one crazy come-from-behind victory). They are playing better than I have ever seen them play.
So here is some Quebec insight for the rest of the country: JM is one of the top 10 teams in the world, and has a real shot at winning his second Brier. I am sure those of you outside of Quebec will point at the World rankings and scoff at my statement. He is currently ranked 17th on the World Order of Merit, and does not figure in the top 10 on the money list.
But hear me out. This team finished 3rd at the last Brier, and has kicked ass in almost every spiel they have played in this year. They lost the final in Gatineau – to Mike McEwen (the best team in the world right now), and then won Charlevoix.   
The reason they are not ranked higher is that they play a “Normal” schedule. That is to say that they do not travel every weekend to slams like the other top teams. They have jobs and families, and just do not want to burn themselves out. Seems like a wise choice; maybe some of the other top teams should take note. Especially Olympic Gold Medalist Brad Jacobs - whose wife just had a baby! Maybe being away 26 weeks per year is not the ideal lifestyle for the elite of our sport. Just sayin'.

Quebec Provincial Notes:
There were a number of compelling story lines to follow all week.
  • Ontario import Lauren Mann won the Scotties event, rather easily at that. She is joined by Brittany O’Rourke who will now play in her 3rd consecutive Scotties, Amélie Blais and Anne-Marie Filtault (you might know her the cute Quebec girl in the Scotties commercial that shows super-close ups of attractive women). They were almost as dominant as Jean-Michel, and never really looked in danger of not winning. I think they will do okay at the Scotties. Not awesome, but should be able to keep Quebec clear of the relegation zone!  I predict a strong, middle-of-the-pack showing.
  • One of the more entertaining features of the week was the Bob Desjardins show. Bob had a strange week. They finished 3-6, yet somehow were not eliminated heading into the final round robin game. Bob had a 5-man team, which he used to rotate players in and out all week. He fired people, then re-hired, then re-fired, then got sick, got better, suggested his team should submit to psychological evaluation, then lost. Somehow Bob manages to be the most-talked about curler in Quebec, even when he goes 3-6. This team should have been a reality TV show. And they had their own hashtag: #Fredsfault.
  • Once again, the Trépannier brothers (now playing with Simon Benoit) proved to be a promising team on the ice, and likely heirs to the title of chief entertainers off the ice. I am still laughing at JF Trépannier discussing an intimate moment from his past that did not end well.  Sorry - not suitable for family reading!
  • Good performance by Roxanne Perron – a young team with which we share our coach: Michel St-Onge. They had a similar week to us: they played well, reached the final and then got outplayed. Hope this team sticks it out for a few years – lots of potential and I am sure they learned a lot from their first final experience.
  • No word on any teams breaking up or staying together – or if there was I missed it (except for Bob’s team I guess).
  • Denis "the Flame" Laflamme did not disappoint in what he claims was his last provincial. He was tough to beat, and pulled off a few upsets.

I have a Dream...
There was a lot of discussion about what should be the format for Quebec provincials - more importantly what we can change to get more teams to sign up.
A meeting will be held with CQ later this month to discuss the format of future provincials (number of teams, regional representation).

But I am starting to think we are missing the boat by talking about the format. My quiet but usually correct lead JF Charest pointed out to me this week: the format is not the problem – the problem is too few teams want to curl in provincials.
Now that I am a Director at Curling Quebec I can’t slam CQ for once again under-promoting what is an excellent event. But I will say that we need to do a better job at selling what could be an excellent showcase for the sport of curling.

Here is my Vision for where I think we need to take Quebec Provincials over the next five years. My plan has 4 points (because all good plans have 4 points):

  1. More Media Exposure (and Better Media Exposure)
  2.  More Visbility – on TV or the Internet
  3. More fun
  4. More sponsorship

More Media Exposure
The Quebec Provincials get no media attention. We are not on RDS, TVA, or in La Presse, the Gazette, QMI or any of the Journal de wherevers. And the usual refrain is to blame the media.
“They are too hockey centric” – “Nobody cares about Curling”. We have thrown in the towel, and assume that we can never get any media for our sport. I think this is wrong.
My experience with communications over the past few years at my job have taught me one thing: the Media is Lazy. They do not like to work. They do not dig. They prefer when stories come to them, and ideally when they are pre-written in an easy to cut and paste press release. They will not cover a sporting event, but will often send a crew to a press conference if they know that a politician will be there.
I think we just need to ask. I think we need to write stories. I think we need to hold a press conference before the event.  I think we need to have a press area with free donuts.
Quebec is in the same position as the rest of the country: multiple sports networks are fighting to fill their airwaves with sellable content. There must be a way to use this to benefit our sport.
More Visibility
My Gatineau game against Adam Casey was web-streamed. The Mixed Nationals were televised. Most other provinces televise the Provincial finals.
How can we not? (Admittedly this year’s final would have been a yawner, but maybe next year will be better!) There needs to be a way to do this.
More Fun:
The fact is that not everybody is there to win. Many teams are there for the experience. Realistically, only half the teams at this year’s event had a realistic chance of winning, yet they were still there. We need to do a better job at making the event fun for them. The Brier has a “Patch”, a bar area where there is live music and entertainment. Quebec provincials had a couple of tables and some veggies with dip. Why is there not  a Friday night party? We used to have a banquet, which the players do not usually care about. But why not have a party instead – ideally after more than half the teams are eliminated. Invite the volunteers, the sponsors, the local curling clubs, and fans! Have a band. We can’t rely on the Trepannier brothers to play AND serve as entertainment directors. Make it an event.

The provincials need to be a rewarding and fun experience for the teams that will not win.

Provincials are very hard to run. They require a ton of volunteers. I think we need to be more judicious about what we ask people to volunteer for.
How many officials do we really need on the ice? There are scorekeepers, people keeping layouts of the house on little magnet boards, head officials, on-ice officials. Let’s cut it down. Let’s use our volunteers to do more fun stuff. Like run parties…or write press releases. Or staff a press area. We need to make the event more fun for volunteers as well.
More Sponsorship.
I think this one will happen when we get the other 3 pieces right. The sad fact is: the event does not deserve more sponsorship money in the way it is held today. It is not spoken about in the media, it does not look fun, and it is not seen by anybody who is not at the arena. If I were a marketing director, I would not sponsor it. We need to make the Quebec Provincials a bigger show before we can hope to rake in a big fish.

To sum up: We need to think big. Quebec provincials should be one of the main tools in CQ’s arsenal to draw exposure and attention to the sport. It can help showcase our best teams, encourage others to take up the sport and provide visibility to the Quebec curling scene. Instead, it has become an event that only curlers hear about, and that has become a chore from an organizational perspective. Let’s fix this.

As usual – Comments are welcome. 


  1. I would be surprised to see Steeve Gagnon's team back together for another year.

  2. I was fortunate enough to catch (Sideshow) Bob Desjardins in Gatineau and Charlevoix. My favourite moment was arriving at the rink and seeing him peel away from the parking lot, leaving his teamate stranded.

    As for the provincials, i think the format is fine, unlike the old reginional and last chance system that allowed for a lot of mediocre teams. CQ showcases the talent. There is no reason why RDS features Texas Hold'em over curling. However to get tv interested their costs have to be low, so maybe the provs should be held in Montreal, Quebec and Gatineau exclusively and NOT in places like Amqui where no one will send a reporter let alone a TV crew!

    As for building up the sport on the participation level. This should be done at the regional level. There is no miracle cure. Mr Joe Curler has many reasons to opt out.

    1) Lower the cash spots, this may seem counter intuitive, but putting the 3rd and 4th best teams in the regionals, gives mr Joe Curler the opportunity to play them, increasing his interest level.

    2) Price tag - price tag is a deterrent. Mr Joe Curler does not have an unlimited budget. where would you spend your budget, buckingham and charlevoix where there are elite curlers beside you? Local cash spiels like BDCC, and the 2 glenmore spiels, where the compitition is equal, the fun level is more and you get cash should you do well. Or do you want to go to the regionals where you see a more middle pack of curlers ( no menards, fourniers ect.) but no local teams either

  3. I think Curling Quebec should try a 12 team triple knockout just like Alberta is doing with the Scotties this week. For provincials, the top 4 teams get a first round bye (Circuit champ and top 3 money winners) and qualify 4 teams out of of the west and east regions who would battle for spots in the A quarter finals. Qualify top 4 for playoffs, A winner plays B winner in the 1 vs 2 game and the 2 C qualifiers play it out in the 3 vs 4 game.

    For the organizers, it's a Wednesday to Sunday tournament, saving costs and time. Same thing for the players.

    12 team triple better than an 8 team triple.